Home   >   CSC-OpenAccess Library   >    Manuscript Information
Selection of the Best Module Design for Ultrafiltration (UF) Membrane in Dairy Industry: An Application of AHP and PROMETHEE
Mohsen Pirdashti, Majid Behzadian
Pages - 426 - 442     |    Revised - 30-10-2009     |    Published - 30-11-2009
Volume - 3   Issue - 5    |    Publication Date - November 2009  Table of Contents
membrane separation, Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), PROMETHEE
Membrane with a type module has been expressed one of the key area of interest in dairy industry. Although recent publications have given a chance academics and practitioners to prove successful applications of membrane processes to the vast areas; a small number of publications have been devoted attention to the problem of capital equipment decision-making. To facilitate decision-making process in the membrane separation, this report focuses on the application of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluations (PROMETHEE), from a group decision-making viewpoint; it uses the Delphi technique to evaluate available alternatives according the criteria elicited from expert's opinions. A real case study on the ultrafiltration membrane area is put forward to determine the best module design based on the five criteria expressed by decision-makers: sanitation design, clean–in-place, packing density, resistance to fouling and shear stress, and relative cost. Finally, the paper utilizes Expert Choice and DECISION LAB software’s to facilitate calculations.
CITED BY (6)  
1 Sadeghravesh, M. H., Khosravi, H., Abolhasani, A., & Shekoohizadeghan, S. (2016). Evaluation of Combating Desertification Alternatives Using Promethee Model. Journal of Geography and Geology, 8(1), 28.
2 Anojkumar, L., Ilangkumaran, M., & Sasirekha, V. (2014). Comparative analysis of MCDM methods for pipe material selection in sugar industry. Expert Systems with Applications, 41(6), 2964-2980.
3 Nasiri, H., Boloorani, A. D., Sabokbar, H. A. F., Jafari, H. R., Hamzeh, M., & Rafii, Y. (2013). Determining the most suitable areas for artificial groundwater recharge via an integrated PROMETHEE II-AHP method in GIS environment (case study: Garabaygan Basin, Iran). Environmental monitoring and assessment, 185(1), 707-718.
4 Ilangkumaran, M., Avenash, A., Balakrishnan, V., Kumar, S. B., & Raja, M. B. (2013). Material selection using hybrid MCDM approach for automobile bumper. International Journal of Industrial and Systems Engineering, 14(1), 20-39.
5 Ghervase, L. U. M. I. N. I. T. A., Cordier, A. N. G. E., Ibalot, F. A. B. I. E. N. N. E., & Parlanti, E. (2012). Storage effect on fluorescence signal of dissolved organic matter components. Romanian Reports in Physics, 64(3), 754-760.
6 Jafari, M. H., & Rafii, Y. Hossein Nasiri, Ali Darvishi Boloorani, Hassan Ali Faraji Sabokbar, Hamid Reza.
1 Google Scholar 
2 Academic Journals Database 
3 ScientificCommons 
4 Academic Index 
5 CiteSeerX 
6 refSeek 
7 iSEEK 
8 Socol@r 
9 ResearchGATE 
10 Libsearch 
11 Bielefeld Academic Search Engine (BASE) 
12 OpenJ-Gate 
13 Scribd 
14 WorldCat 
15 SlideShare 
16 PdfSR 
18 Chinese Directory Of Open Access 
2. B.Jiao, A.Cassano, E. Drioli. “Recent Advances on Membrane Processes for the Concentration of Fruit Juices: A Review“. Journal of Food Engineering, 63: 303-324, 2004
C.Macharis, A.Verbeke, K. De Brucker. ‘The strategic evaluation of new technologies through multi-criteria analysis: the advisors case’, in Bekiaris E. and Y. Nakanishi (eds.) Economic impacts of Intelligent Transport Systems. Innovations and case studies, Elsevier, Amsterdam (2004)
Ch.Okoli, S. Pawlwoski . “The Delphi method as a research tool: an example, design considerations and applications“. Journal of Information and Management, 42: 15-29, 2004
Cousins, R.B. “ Membrane Technology“. Department of Chemical and Process Engineering University of Strathclyde in Glasgow (2003-2004)
D. H. Byun, “The AHP approach for selecting an automobile purchase model“. Information & Management, 38: 289-297, 2001
Dalkey, C., Norman, L. R. Daniel, R.Lewis, D. Snyder,” Studies in the Quality of Life, Delphi and Decision-Making”, Lexington Books, PP. 20-21(1972)
Decision Lab 2000-Getting started Guide. “www.visualdecision.com” “Visual Decision Inc. Montreal, Canada (1999)
F.Niederman, J.C. Brancheau, J.C Wetherbe. “Information systems management issues for the 1990s“. MIS Quarterly, 15(4): 474-500, 1991
J.F. Preble. “The selection of delphi panels for strategic planning purposes“. Strategic Management Journal, 5(2): 157-170, 1984
J.J.Wang, D.L. Yang. “Using a hybrid multi-criteria decision aid method for information systems outsourcing“. Computers & Operations Research 34: 3691– 3700, 2007
J.P. Brans, P.Vincke. “A preference ranking organization method. The PROMETHEE method for MCDM“. Management Science, 31: 641-656, 1985
J.P.Brans, B.Mareschal. “ PROMETHEE V–MCDM problems with segmentation constraints“. INFOR, 30(2): 85-96, 1992
J.S. Dyer . “A clarification of Remarks on the analytic hierarchy process“. Management Science, 36: 274-275, 1990b
J.S. Dyer. “ Remarks on the analytic hierarchy process“. Management Science, 36: 249-258, 1990a
J.Schwinge, P.R.Neal, S.E.Wiley, D.F.Fltcher, A.G Fane . “Spiral Wound Modules and Spacers: Review and Analysis“. Journal of Membrane Science, 242: 129-153, 2004
J.Wagner. “Membrane Filtration Handbook Practical Tips and Hints“. Second Edition, Revision 2 (2001)
K. Brockoff. “ Group process for forecasting“. European Journal of Operational Research, 13(2),115-127, 1983
K. M. Al-Subhi Al-harbi. “Application of the AHP in project management“. International Journal of Project Management, 19: 19-27, 2001
L.Vargas. “ An overview of analytic hierarchy process: Its applications”, European Journal of Operational Research 48 (1) 2–8, 1990
M. T.Escobar, J.Aguaron, J. M. Moreno-Jimenes. “ A note on AHP group consistency for the row geometric mean priorization procedure“. European Journal of Operational Research, 153: 318-322, 2004
M.Janic, A. Reggiani. “An Application of the Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) Analysis to the Selection of a New Hub Airport“. EJTIR, 2(2): 113-14, 2002
M.K. Malhotra, D.C. Steele, V. Grover.“Important strategic and tactical manufacturing issues in the 1990s“. Decision Sciences, 25(2): 189-214, 1994
M.Tavana, D.T Kennedy. “ N-site: a distributed consensus building and negotiation support system“. International Journal of Information Technology and Decision Making, 5(1): 123-154, 2006
M.Tavana, D.T. Kennedy , B.Leauby, J. Ugras. “An investigation of the relative importance of the characteristics of information in governmental financial reporting“. Business Journal, 19(1-2), 56-62, 2004
M.Tavana, D.T. Kennedy, B. Mohebbi. “Total quality index: a benchmarking tool for total quality management“. Benchmarking: An International Journal, 10(6): 507-527, 2003
M.Tavana, D.T.Kennedy, P.Joglekar. “A group decision support framework for consensus ranking of technical manager candidates“. Omega, International Journal of Management Science, 24: 523-538. 1996
N.G.Hall, J.C.Hershey, L.G. Kessler, R.C. Stotts. “A model for making project funding decisions at the national cancer institute“. Operations Research, 40(6): 1040-1052, 1992
Oak Ridge National Laboratory. “ Materials for Separation Technologies: Energy and Emission Reduction Opportunities“. Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy, U.S Department of Energy, Oak Ridge,TN 37830, (2005)
P.Le-Clech. Z. Cao, P.Y.Wan, D.E.Wiley, A.G Fane. “The application of constant temperature anemometry to membrane processes“. Journal of membrane science, 284: 416-423, 2006
P.T. Harker, L.G. Vargas. “Reply to ‘remarks on the analytic hierarchy process by J.S. Dyer“. Management Science, 36, 269-273, 1990
P.T.Harker, L.G. Vargas. “ The theory of ratio scale estimation: Saaty’s analytic hierarchy process“. Management Science, 33:1383-1403,1987
R. Bijl. “Delphi in a future scenario study on mental health and mental health care“. Futures, 24(3): 232-250, 1992
R.P.Hudak, Jr. P.P. Brooke, K. Finstuen. P.Riley. “Health care administration in the year 2000: practioners“. views of future issues and job requirements. Hospital and Health Services Administration, 38(2): 181-195, 1993
R.U.Bilsel, G.Buyukozkan, D. Ruan. “A fuzzy preference-ranking model for a quality evaluation of hospital web sites“. International Journal of Intelligent Systems 21: 1181–1197, 2006
S. Ali, P.Boblak, E.Capili, S.Milidovich. “ Membrane Separation and Ultrafiltration“, CHE-396 Senior Design.,(1998).
S.Muthukumaran, S.E.Kenitish, M. Ashokkumar, G.W. Stevens. “Mechanisms for the ultrasonic enhancement of dairy whey ultrafiltration“. Journal of membrane science, 258: 106-114, 2005
S.S.Madaeni, S.Zereshki. “Membrane Technology as a Promising Alternative for Less Energy Consumption in Food Industry“. In Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Energy Research and Development (ICERD- 3), 2006
T. L. Saaty. “ Eigenvector and logarithmic least squares”, European Journal of Operational Research 48: 156-160, 1990
T.E Weinberger. “ The strategic centrality of jobs: a measure of value“. Compensation and Benefits Review, 24(1), 61-68, 1992
T.L. Saaty. “ The Analytical Hierarchy Process“. Mc Graw-Hill. New York, (1980)
T.L. Saaty. “An exposition of the AHP in reply to the paper ‘Remarks on the analytic hierarchy process“. Management Science, 36: 259-268, 1990b
T.L. Saaty. “Axiomatic foundations of the analytic hierarchy process“. Management Science, 32: 841-855, 1983
T.L. Saaty. “Highlights and critical points in theory and application of the analytical hierarchy process“. European Journal of Operational Research, 74: 426-447, 1994a
T.L. Saaty. “How to make a decision: the analytic hierarchy process“. Interfaces, 24: 19-43, 1994b
T.L. Saaty. “How to make a decision: the analytical hierarchy process“. European Journal of Operational Research, North-Holland, 48: 9-26,1990a
T.L. Saaty. “Modeling unstructured decision problems: a theory of analytical hierarchies“. In Proceedings of the First International Conference on Mathematical Modeling, St. Louis, Missouri, 69–77, 1977
T.L. Saaty.” Decision making for leaders”. Pittsburgh, PA: RWS Publications (1982)
V. S.Lai, B. K.Wong, W. Cheung. “Group decision making in a multiple criteria environment: A case using the AHP in software selection“. European Journal of Operational Research, 137: 134-144,2002
W.Eykamp. “Membrane Separation Processes in Perry’s Chemical Engineers Handbook“.7th (Eds), Mc Graw-Hill,NY.22.39-22.39-22.41(1997)
Z.Babic, N.Plazibat. “Ranking of enterprises based on multicriterial analysis“. International Journal of Production Economics, 29–35, 1998
Z.Xu. “On consistency of the weighted geometric mean complex judgment matrix in AHP“. European Journal of Operational Research, 126, 683-687, 2000
Mr. Mohsen Pirdashti
Shomal University - Iran
Dr. Majid Behzadian
Shomal University - Iran